How many carats should an engagement ring have?

The moment you ask, "Will you marry me?" – the engagement, a moment full of magic. And the ring should be just as special. But then the big question arises: How many carats should an engagement ring weigh?

Is 1 carat the new ideal? Or are delicate, carefully chosen diamonds a more beautiful expression of true love? In this guide, you'll learn everything about carat weight, diamond size, and how to find the engagement ring that suits you—and your values. Let's go!

What does carat mean in an engagement ring?

If you're wondering what carat actually means, here's the short version: Carat is the unit of weight for diamonds. 1 carat equals 0.2 grams. However, more carats aren't automatically better.

In addition to carat weight, cut, color, and clarity also play a role in an engagement ring. These criteria are also known as the "4Cs." A smaller, well-cut diamond can shine more brightly than a larger one with less brilliance. Therefore, it's worth considering the overall appearance—not just the number.

How many carats for an engagement ring – 1 carat or more: what is “normal”?

We often hear the question , "How many carats should I get for an engagement ring?" Many people choose between 0.25 and 0.50 carats because this range offers a nice balance of elegance, everyday practicality, and affordability.

A 1-carat engagement ring is considered a classic—presentable, but not over the top. 5-carat models, on the other hand, are true showpieces—eye-catching, heavy, and for many, rather impractical for everyday wear.

Deliberately minimalist designs are particularly popular. Those who opt for delicate engagement rings (gold or silver), for example, demonstrate that it's the gesture that counts, not the size.

Carat vs. cut – what makes the engagement ring diamond special?

When considering "How many carats should I get for an engagement ring?", it's often forgotten that the diamond cut also significantly influences the look. A brilliant round cut maximizes the value of a smaller carat weight. An oval cut makes the stone appear larger, even though it weighs less.

That's why it's worth taking a second look – sometimes the 0.5-carat diamond ring with the perfect cut is the real star. And: Cuts can also influence the price without you even noticing.

How much should an engagement ring cost?

The cost of an engagement ring depends heavily on the carat—but also on the material, cut, and origin of the diamond. A 1-carat diamond ring can cost several thousand euros.

More and more lovebirds are therefore consciously choosing alternatives: Lab-grown diamonds, for example, look just as precious but are more sustainable – and more affordable. Our sustainable engagement rings feature recycled gold and ethically sourced stones – for responsible beauty.

The monthly salary rule – still relevant?

The classic monthly salary rule states that an engagement ring should cost about one to three months' salary. But let's be honest: love can't be measured in money.

What's much more important is what feels right for you. " How many carats should my engagement ring have? " isn't just a stylistic or price-related decision, but also an emotional one.

Engagement ring vs. wedding ring – does carat play a role in both?

When it comes to carats, many people first think of engagement rings. But what about wedding rings? There are differences here, too—especially in terms of design.

The engagement ring often represents the "big moment": the marriage proposal, the surprise, the emotional "I do!" Therefore, the diamond can take center stage here—in the classic solitaire or as a minimalist setting. The carat weight of an engagement ring is usually higher to create a visible accent.

Wedding rings, on the other hand, are often more understated, everyday designs. Many opt for simple models without stones or with very subtle diamonds. If a stone is present, the carat weight is usually significantly lower than that of an engagement ring—often less than 0.1 carat.

It's all in the combination: a sparkling 0.3–1 carat engagement ring and a puristic wedding ring create a clean look that suits every style – and makes every story unique.

Which style suits which carat weight?

The question of style often helps when deciding how many carats an engagement ring should have. Those who prefer a minimalist look often opt for smaller stones between 0.25 and 0.40 carats. These sizes look particularly elegant and understated in clean settings or narrow rings – like our delicate gold engagement rings .

A 1-carat engagement ring is ideal for those who love pure elegance. Those who prefer a grand entrance can make a statement with several smaller stones or a striking 1.5-2 carat solitaire – without appearing over the top.

Buying an engagement ring: Ring size – without a ring?

Are you planning a surprise proposal but have no idea what ring size is right for you? Don't worry, there are tricks to figure out your engagement ring size without the ring.

In our guide, we'll show you how to discreetly and precisely find the right size: Engagement ring - Finding your size without a ring . We've got you covered!

How many carats should you choose for an engagement ring? Just as much as suits you.

In the end, it's not about the numbers. It's about what feels right. Whether 0.3 carats or 1 carat, delicate, sparkling, or minimalist—an engagement ring should tell your story. You do you!

So don't listen to old rules. Instead, ask yourself how the ring suits you. Your style. Your everyday life. Your feelings. Discover sustainable gold engagement rings – made for modern declarations of love with character.